Study for "A Woman Seated Beside a Vase of Flowers (Madame Paul Valpinçon?)"

Graphite

Black crayon, squared in black chalk, on off-white antique laid paper

Watercolor and graphite on cream wove paper

Black crayon on off-white antique laid paper

Black chalk with erasure on cream antique laid paper

Gray ink and brown wash over graphite on cream modern paper, laid down to faded blue antique laid paper

Brown ink, brown wash and graphite on cream wove paper

Graphite on cream wove paper

Graphite on white modern laid paper

Black ink on tracing paper, darkened and mounted to laid paper

Black chalk heightened with white chalk and white gouache on blue wove paper