The Adoration of the Shepherds; verso: The Virgin and Child in the Clouds, Surrounded by Angels

Black chalk on off-white antique laid paper

Brown ink over black chalk on cream antique laid paper, the whole sheet later retouched with light brown-gray wash; framing line in brown ink, mounted overall

Brown ink and gray wash over black chalk on off-white antique laid paper

Brown ink and gray wash on cream antique laid paper, framing line in black ink

Brown ink and brown and gray wash over graphite on cream antique laid paper, framing line in brown ink

Black chalk on light tan antique laid paper, framing line in brown ink; verso: black chalk

Black and red chalk and touches of white opaque watercolor on off-white antique laid paper, framing line in wetted red chalk and on right edge a brighter wetted right chalk with dots of white opaque watercolor

Brown ink and gray and blue wash over black chalk on off-white antique laid paper, partial framing line in graphite laid down

Brown ink, brown wash, transparent watercolor, and touches of blue chalk on cream antique laid paper

Red chalk and brown ink on off-white antique laid paper, upper edge repaired with irregular strip; verso: rubbed with red chalk [presumably for transfer]

Black, red, and white chalk and brown and gray wash on cream antique laid paper, laid down

Brown ink, black chalk and white opaque watercolor on off-white antique laid paper, partial framing line in brown ink, possibly autograph