Madonna and Child Enthroned with Four Saints

Brown ink, black chalk, brown wash and white gouache on off-white antique laid paper, toned overall with a pale brown wash

Brown ink, brown wash and traces of graphite on cream antique laid paper, laid down to off-white antique laid paper

Black chalk, brown ink, brown wash and white gouache, on cream antique laid paper prepared with a pale tan wash

Brown ink and brown wash over black chalk on blue-green antique laid paper, laid down

Brown ink, brown wash, black chalk on cream antique-laid paper

Brown ink on dark cream antique laid paper, partially laid down to two layers of cream antique laid paper

Brown ink and wash squared in black chalk on cream antique laid paper with red chalk offset lower center; verso: faint black chalk sketch

Black chalk on off-white antique laid paper; verso: black chalk

Brown ink on cream antique laid paper, squared in red chalk, laid down overall on cream antique laid decorated mount of John Barnard (?)

Red chalk on buff antique laid paper, slightly retouched with different red chalk; pricked for transfer

Brown ink and brown wash on cream antique laid paper prepared with gray wash

Black and brown ink, brown wash, heightened with white gouache, on tan antique laid paper