Portrait of Madame Charles Hayard and Her Daughter Caroline

Graphite on cream modern laid paper

Black ink on tracing paper with a laid paper framing mount

Charcoal on tracing paper

Oil on paper over traces of graphite

Red chalk on cream paper

Black ink on tracing paper, darkened and mounted to laid paper

Graphite, squared, on white wove paper

Brown wash and white gouache over graphite and black chalk on brown wove paper

Graphite on pale gray modern laid paper

Black crayon over graphite, squared in graphite, on off-white antique laid paper

Black and white chalk on buff laid paper; verso: black chalk

Brown and black ink, brown wash, and graphite on toned cream antique laid paper, laid down on cream antique laid paper with blue paper strips adhered to face