Boats under a Cliff

Red chalk and black crayon

Black crayon, squared in black crayon, on off-white antique laid paper

Charcoal, black and white chalk, and traces of white opaque watercolor, squared in black chalk, on green-gray wove paper, discolored to tan

Red chalk on dark tan wove paper, discolored

Black ink, red chalk, gray wash, and white gouache over black chalk, on blue antique laid paper; verso: black ink and gray wash

Black chalk on off-white modern laid paper

Graphite on white wove paper

Black chalk, squared in graphite, on tracing paper

Graphite on pale gray modern laid paper

Black chalk

Brown ink and brown wash on thin white wove paper

Watercolor and black and brown ink over graphite on white wove paper