Copy after Raphael's Mass at Bolsena

Graphite on modern laid paper

Black ink, gray wash, and gouache on off-white wove paper, slightly darkened

Black ink on albumen photographic paper

Graphite on cream wove paper, backed, traced with a stylus after mounting, squared

Black chalk with traces of charcoal with scraping on cream antique laid paper; graphite outline on palette and lower edge of coat lapels (later addition?)

Gouache and watercolor over graphite on off-white Japan paper, laid down on cream antique laid paper

Black crayon, squared in black crayon, on off-white antique laid paper

Charcoal and pastel on off-white wove paper

graphite on white modern laid paper; touches of gray watercolor at the upper corners

Red chalk over black chalk on off-white antique laid paper