Adoration of the Shepherds

Brown ink and black chalk on off-white antique laid paper; verso: black chalk

Brown ink and brown wash on cream antique laid paper

Brown ink and brown wash over black chalk, incised throughout, on off-white antique laid paper, framing line in brown ink

Brown ink and brown wash over traces of black chalk on light tan antique laid paper

Brown ink and wash on cream paper

Brown ink over graphite, with a framing line in black ink, on cream antique laid paper

Brown ink on cream antique laid paper, with an original framing line in brown ink and a later partial framing line in brown ink

Black chalk, brown ink, and gray and brown wash on off-white antique laid paper, framing line in black ink and in black chalk

Brown ink and brown wash and white opaque watercolor on prepared antique laid paper

Transparent watercolor, black ink, and gray wash, incised and silhouetted, on cream antique laid paper

Black ink, black wash, traces of black chalk; incised extensively, laid down, framing line in brown ink at bottom and partially at top, right, and left on cream antique laid paper

Gray wash with black chalk and graphite, green and rose transparent watercolor, scraping and traces of white opaque watercolor on cream antique laid paper, toned with brown wash, framing lines in graphite and gray wash