Illegible sketch; verso: Landscape with a Shepherd and His Flock

Black chalk, black ink, gray wash, and white opaque watercolor, with a framing line in brown ink, on cream antique laid paper, prepared with brown wash

Red chalk on cream antique laid paper, partial framing lines in brown ink and graphite

Oil, with pricked outlines, on cream antique laid paper

Graphite and black chalk on beige antique laid paper

Black and white chalk, charcoal, and gray wash on blue antique laid paper, autograph framing line in charcoal; verso: test strokes in white chalk

Brown ink on off-white antique laid paper, framing lines in brown ink

Brown ink, brown wash, black chalk, and later touches of white chalk on light tan antique laid paper prepared with light tan wash, partial framing line in black chalk at upper edge

Brown ink and brown wash on cream antique laid paper

Black ink, gray and brown wash, and red and blue transparent watercolor over graphite on cream antique laid paper

Black ink, gray wash, and white opaque watercolor over black chalk on off-white antique laid paper, framing line in black ink

Two tones of brown ink over graphite on cream antique laid paper; verso: brown ink over graphite

Graphite and red chalk on vellum