Adoration of the Shepherds

Red chalk on cream antique laid paper

Brown ink over red chalk and traces of graphite on cream antique laid paper, squared in red chalk, framing lines in brown ink

Black ink and gray wash

Brown and gray ink, gray wash, and graphite, with touches of white gouache on off-white antique laid paper, framing lines in brown ink and gray wash

Red and white chalk with traces of graphite on tan antique laid paper; verso: darkened

Black and white chalk on light tan antique laid paper

Red chalk on cream antique laid paper

Black chalk on cream antique laid paper

Brown ink and brown wash on cream antique laid paper, framing lines in red chalk and brown ink, laid down on cream antique laid paper

Tracings, mostly in graphite, occasionally supplemented with gray wash, on cream antique laid paper

Brown and black ink, brown wash, and watercolor on parchment, partial framing line in black ink; verso: traces of graphite

Graphite on cream antique laid paper